through April 4. That appears to be how I'm doing this now.
Completed books:
Caramelo, by Sandra Cisneros slightly magical realist Mexican family saga
Jackaby, by William Ritter, urban fantasy/post-steampunk vol 1 of a series
I'll Never Get Out of this World Alive, by Steve Earle, fantasy/magical realism, the latter life of Hank WIlliams's discredited doctor, and Hank's ghost and...
Fangirl, by Rainbow Rowell, YA college freshmen romcom
Sag Harbor, by Colson Whitehead, semi-autobiographical coming of age novel
New York 2140, by Kim Stanley Robinson, midfuture epic
Ghostly Echoes, by WIlliam Ritter, 3rd in Jackaby series
The Cardturner, by Louis Sachar, YA comic-drama coming of age story involving bridge and awful moneygrubbing parents
A Princess in Theory, by Alyssa Cole, surprise African royalty romance with an orphan scientist
Jepp, Who Defied the Stars, by Katherine Marsh, YA historical coming of age disability science romance-adjacent
Books dropped before the end:
Cloud Atlas, by David Mitchell
Makers, by Cory Doctorow
The Reader, by Traci Chee
Wickedly Charming, by Kristine Grayson
Let me get the dropped books out of the way first. Cloud Atlas has some cool characters in it, but it's a setup to prove that humanity is bad and terrible and the worst ones will always win. I gave up maybe 75% of the way through. I do like the gimmick structure--a series of unfinished stories, whose "and then what happened?" is revealed in the story of a later character with only tangential, but at the same time substantive and consequential, connections to the earlier character. But that, and the really quite nice writing, are not enough to elevate the book from the tedious sophomoric "moral."
I was enjoying the hell out of Makers and would have finished it but nobody I knew could assure me that the next bit coming up wasn't going to be a second life-destroying physical attack on a main character graphically and lavishly described for many harrowing pages possibly resulting in the permanent maiming or death of the character. The fact that this character was a woman only opened up even more awful possibilities than the first attack, which nearly finished me. Nobody who talks about this book even notes that the first attack takes place, so the fact that the second potential one isn't mentioned is no kind of evidence at all. There was no reason for the way the first one was written except to highlight the erection that the attacker had.
The Reader is mischaracterized in its publicity materials. It's not about a world with no readers in it, where there is one magical book and one unlikely person who learns to read. It is about assassins. It's well written but not my cup of tea.
Wickedly Charming starts out with the premise that the archetypes of modern versions of fairytales are based on distortions of the real lives of people from backward but very magical countries. The stepmothers' lives have been outright lied about. Two expats from that world, Snow White's stepmother and Cinderella's divorced Prince Charming, collaborate on a novel meant to Tell The Whole Real Truth and have a light romantic comedy of their own while they're at it. And then, halfway through the book, we jump the shark and there's a bunch of artificially injected Plot with Nasty Villains in it, and all the fun goes out of the book as we stare slackjawed at the introduction of dumb stereotyped antagonists. Talk about missing one's own point.
Okay, the finished ones:
Caramelo This is a rush. I definitely recommend listening to this one rather than reading it, because CIsneros reads it herself andf her voice is soooo perfect for this. Also, while the title is explained by several bits in the story--the fundamental one being the name of the design of the unfinished rebozo that is handed down in the family-- it also describes the impact of the story's structure. The import of every little detail-and every little detail has import-spreads sweetly across your brain like the sugar of candy that you suck for a long time: and then, suddenly, something explodes like when you crunch down on a filled candy. CIsneros reads it in a sweet, high-pitched rush, sometimes full of mirth, other times outrage, other times, deep sympathy. Read it! Or better, listen to it.
Oops I didn't tell you anything about the story. Several generations of a Mexican family reveal their secrets to the modern daughter, especially "The Awful Grandmother" who, it turns out, has her reasons.
Jackaby A plucky middle class English maiden arrives in a fictional Massachusetts town in the late 1800s, in need of a job after having finished out a stint working on a paleontological dig in Ukraine. She crosses paths with a Seer who is fighting mostly fairytale creatures. This is a four-book series and apparently the stakes accelerate a lot. This is a category of book I usually avoid because I'm not fond of Jim Butcher or Laurell K. Hamilton, but these are their own thing. They have a little Dr. Who feel due to the title character's eccentricity and odd clothing, but the POV character is more than an observer, and the side characters all amount to something interesting.
I'll Never Get Out of This World Alive More than a decade after he screwed up and accidentally killed Hank Williams with a drug overdose, the doctor is a junkie, patching up gangsters and providing illegal abortions to afford his next fix. He's haunted by Hank Williams's sarcastic and apparently vindictive ghost. And then... everything changes because he provides an abortion for the granddaughter of a curandero, who is just now ready to come into her own powers and use the teachings of her grandpa. This is written by the musician Steve Earle. I believe he avoids the exoticism trap pretty well when he depicts the young woman's point of view. I liked this book a lot.
Fangirl I think a lot of people were mad at this book for one reason or another, but I liked it. The protagonist is one of a pair of twins, freshmen at college, who have always done everything together until recently. The other twin has been fighting to separate herself, and it's not going well for our protagonist, who has some mental issues she handles either well or not depending on the circumstances. While her sister gets in over her head with the fast-living frat-adjacent crowd, the protagonist struggles with the divide between fan writing and mainstream writing (with a teacher who thinks all fan writing is at its core plagiarism, but has some good points about how to write mainstream writing: and an exploitive cowriter) There's a lot more plot: a mother who abandoned them, a manic father (I think it's not bipolarism), a couple of surprise friends. I thought it was a pleasant book.
Sag Harbor So apparently rich kid books are a lot more interesting if they are black rich kids. This is an amiable "how I spent the summer of my junior year" ramble, which I guess wasn't really supposed to be out to show how rich kid privilege gets totally undermined by race, but it does do that, while also telling a sweet coming of age story. I haven't read his serious science fiction books yet: I mean to, but the subjects of them make me ancxious, so I thought I'd read this first to get attached to the author before going there.
New York 2140 Kim Stanley Robinson annoyed the hell out of me with the Mars books: I didn't finish the first one because of grotesque stereotyping and I only glanced into the others before giving up. But I loved the California ones. This is more like those. It's pretty damn fine. It has the post-apocalyptic setup but it's not about the post-apocalyptic premise, at all. It's really germane to now, obviously, and though it has a deus ex machina in it, it's weird enough and fun enough that you don't really mind too much, also because the deus ex machina would not be enough without the collective and political action of, well, basically, New York.
Also I'm really looking forward to N.K.Jemisin's The City We Became, which is a different take on New York resiliency.
Ghostly Echoes The 3rd book of the Jackaby series, which I read out of order because availability: I don't think it's a problem, though they afre definitely in a progression.
The Cardturner Did you read Holes? Then you'll understand why I grabbed this book even though it's about bridge. The card game. I mean, that's not entirely true, I love books that are also about a thing, a world that people inhabit, like that. The blurb was a little more saccharine than necessary, but I trust this author! It turns out it's another book that is probably improved by being read by the author. The protagonist's parents are trying to get him to develop a favorite-uncle relationship with a great-uncle because they want to inherit from him. The opportunity arises because the old man has gone blind from diabetes and he needs a cardturner to help him play bridge, since he has just fired another teenager because she questioned his choices. There's a long-buried complicated love story, and a tentative relationship developing between the teenagers, and problems with longstanding friendships, and and and. And also hefty asides to teach bridge. I thought it was a lot of fun, though aspects of the plot were inevitable and therefore predictable.
A Princess In Theory I have a... complicated relationship with romance. In theory, I should love romance. I certainly love reading about romance books. In practice I am more likely to like reading books that are more what I would call "romance-adjacent"--there's a relationship story there, but there's another main focus to it. One rule that usually works for me is to avoid books with royalty in the title -- like anything "The Duke's Mistress" or whatever. Because I do enjoy reading about romances, I have heard rather a lot about Alyssa Cole, so I was quite willing to break that rule and test whether I would like this book. I kind of do. The protagonist is an epidemiologist! Very timely (even before the pandemic. We always knew the pandemic was coming). (this book does not have a pandemic in it)
I did like it, and I understand why Alyssa Cole has such stalwart fans. Among the pluses: it's sort of a Wakanda novel: the fictional African country has managed to mostly avoid colonization and so therefore is more prosperous and less unequal than other countries. Though there's some weird justification for the excesses of the palace. Cole is quite clearly trying to have her twirly princess dress and her social justice too, and that's fine. A strong plus for some people (including me at some time in the past) is its sex positivity. In romance categories I think it is what is called "sexy" rather than "erotic:" if I understand the difference, the former has sex in it, the latter is centered on sex or sexuality (and pornography is writing that is sex itself). At this stage of my life, written sex is very "meh" to me, so that after the first sex scene, I skipped forward over the others. I don't know why! I do the same with most fight and battle scenes.
The romance was fine, the descriptions of not-Wakanda were very nice, the slice of life in New York were nice. I wasn't satisfied with the mystery B plot. I felt that it could have been a lot more interesting and consequential. The revelation of what happened with the protagonist's parents seemed to me to fall flat completely--as if Cole had actually worked out something that made full sense, had consequence, and actually explained what happened--and then didn't write it into the final draft because of word limits or deadlines or ennui or something.
Jepp This is based on the existence, at Tycho Brahe's Uraniborg castle, of a Dutch dwarf named Jepp and a tippling moose. It tells a fictional tale of how he got there and what he did after he got there. I tried checking on the romance but wasn't able to verify it. I hope it was true. I'm certain that the family origins are fictional, and his life at the court of the Infanta in Brussels: though her fondness for dwarfs and what she put them through is historical fact. The high drama and angst of the book are not just provided by the harrowing events in it, but also by the fact that they are the reminiscences of an innocent teenager in the wide world for the first time. Characters have depth, and the landscape is well-drawn. I just finished it and that's why I'm finally writing these books up!
Completed books:
Caramelo, by Sandra Cisneros slightly magical realist Mexican family saga
Jackaby, by William Ritter, urban fantasy/post-steampunk vol 1 of a series
I'll Never Get Out of this World Alive, by Steve Earle, fantasy/magical realism, the latter life of Hank WIlliams's discredited doctor, and Hank's ghost and...
Fangirl, by Rainbow Rowell, YA college freshmen romcom
Sag Harbor, by Colson Whitehead, semi-autobiographical coming of age novel
New York 2140, by Kim Stanley Robinson, midfuture epic
Ghostly Echoes, by WIlliam Ritter, 3rd in Jackaby series
The Cardturner, by Louis Sachar, YA comic-drama coming of age story involving bridge and awful moneygrubbing parents
A Princess in Theory, by Alyssa Cole, surprise African royalty romance with an orphan scientist
Jepp, Who Defied the Stars, by Katherine Marsh, YA historical coming of age disability science romance-adjacent
Books dropped before the end:
Cloud Atlas, by David Mitchell
Makers, by Cory Doctorow
The Reader, by Traci Chee
Wickedly Charming, by Kristine Grayson
Let me get the dropped books out of the way first. Cloud Atlas has some cool characters in it, but it's a setup to prove that humanity is bad and terrible and the worst ones will always win. I gave up maybe 75% of the way through. I do like the gimmick structure--a series of unfinished stories, whose "and then what happened?" is revealed in the story of a later character with only tangential, but at the same time substantive and consequential, connections to the earlier character. But that, and the really quite nice writing, are not enough to elevate the book from the tedious sophomoric "moral."
I was enjoying the hell out of Makers and would have finished it but nobody I knew could assure me that the next bit coming up wasn't going to be a second life-destroying physical attack on a main character graphically and lavishly described for many harrowing pages possibly resulting in the permanent maiming or death of the character. The fact that this character was a woman only opened up even more awful possibilities than the first attack, which nearly finished me. Nobody who talks about this book even notes that the first attack takes place, so the fact that the second potential one isn't mentioned is no kind of evidence at all. There was no reason for the way the first one was written except to highlight the erection that the attacker had.
The Reader is mischaracterized in its publicity materials. It's not about a world with no readers in it, where there is one magical book and one unlikely person who learns to read. It is about assassins. It's well written but not my cup of tea.
Wickedly Charming starts out with the premise that the archetypes of modern versions of fairytales are based on distortions of the real lives of people from backward but very magical countries. The stepmothers' lives have been outright lied about. Two expats from that world, Snow White's stepmother and Cinderella's divorced Prince Charming, collaborate on a novel meant to Tell The Whole Real Truth and have a light romantic comedy of their own while they're at it. And then, halfway through the book, we jump the shark and there's a bunch of artificially injected Plot with Nasty Villains in it, and all the fun goes out of the book as we stare slackjawed at the introduction of dumb stereotyped antagonists. Talk about missing one's own point.
Okay, the finished ones:
Caramelo This is a rush. I definitely recommend listening to this one rather than reading it, because CIsneros reads it herself andf her voice is soooo perfect for this. Also, while the title is explained by several bits in the story--the fundamental one being the name of the design of the unfinished rebozo that is handed down in the family-- it also describes the impact of the story's structure. The import of every little detail-and every little detail has import-spreads sweetly across your brain like the sugar of candy that you suck for a long time: and then, suddenly, something explodes like when you crunch down on a filled candy. CIsneros reads it in a sweet, high-pitched rush, sometimes full of mirth, other times outrage, other times, deep sympathy. Read it! Or better, listen to it.
Oops I didn't tell you anything about the story. Several generations of a Mexican family reveal their secrets to the modern daughter, especially "The Awful Grandmother" who, it turns out, has her reasons.
Jackaby A plucky middle class English maiden arrives in a fictional Massachusetts town in the late 1800s, in need of a job after having finished out a stint working on a paleontological dig in Ukraine. She crosses paths with a Seer who is fighting mostly fairytale creatures. This is a four-book series and apparently the stakes accelerate a lot. This is a category of book I usually avoid because I'm not fond of Jim Butcher or Laurell K. Hamilton, but these are their own thing. They have a little Dr. Who feel due to the title character's eccentricity and odd clothing, but the POV character is more than an observer, and the side characters all amount to something interesting.
I'll Never Get Out of This World Alive More than a decade after he screwed up and accidentally killed Hank Williams with a drug overdose, the doctor is a junkie, patching up gangsters and providing illegal abortions to afford his next fix. He's haunted by Hank Williams's sarcastic and apparently vindictive ghost. And then... everything changes because he provides an abortion for the granddaughter of a curandero, who is just now ready to come into her own powers and use the teachings of her grandpa. This is written by the musician Steve Earle. I believe he avoids the exoticism trap pretty well when he depicts the young woman's point of view. I liked this book a lot.
Fangirl I think a lot of people were mad at this book for one reason or another, but I liked it. The protagonist is one of a pair of twins, freshmen at college, who have always done everything together until recently. The other twin has been fighting to separate herself, and it's not going well for our protagonist, who has some mental issues she handles either well or not depending on the circumstances. While her sister gets in over her head with the fast-living frat-adjacent crowd, the protagonist struggles with the divide between fan writing and mainstream writing (with a teacher who thinks all fan writing is at its core plagiarism, but has some good points about how to write mainstream writing: and an exploitive cowriter) There's a lot more plot: a mother who abandoned them, a manic father (I think it's not bipolarism), a couple of surprise friends. I thought it was a pleasant book.
Sag Harbor So apparently rich kid books are a lot more interesting if they are black rich kids. This is an amiable "how I spent the summer of my junior year" ramble, which I guess wasn't really supposed to be out to show how rich kid privilege gets totally undermined by race, but it does do that, while also telling a sweet coming of age story. I haven't read his serious science fiction books yet: I mean to, but the subjects of them make me ancxious, so I thought I'd read this first to get attached to the author before going there.
New York 2140 Kim Stanley Robinson annoyed the hell out of me with the Mars books: I didn't finish the first one because of grotesque stereotyping and I only glanced into the others before giving up. But I loved the California ones. This is more like those. It's pretty damn fine. It has the post-apocalyptic setup but it's not about the post-apocalyptic premise, at all. It's really germane to now, obviously, and though it has a deus ex machina in it, it's weird enough and fun enough that you don't really mind too much, also because the deus ex machina would not be enough without the collective and political action of, well, basically, New York.
Also I'm really looking forward to N.K.Jemisin's The City We Became, which is a different take on New York resiliency.
Ghostly Echoes The 3rd book of the Jackaby series, which I read out of order because availability: I don't think it's a problem, though they afre definitely in a progression.
The Cardturner Did you read Holes? Then you'll understand why I grabbed this book even though it's about bridge. The card game. I mean, that's not entirely true, I love books that are also about a thing, a world that people inhabit, like that. The blurb was a little more saccharine than necessary, but I trust this author! It turns out it's another book that is probably improved by being read by the author. The protagonist's parents are trying to get him to develop a favorite-uncle relationship with a great-uncle because they want to inherit from him. The opportunity arises because the old man has gone blind from diabetes and he needs a cardturner to help him play bridge, since he has just fired another teenager because she questioned his choices. There's a long-buried complicated love story, and a tentative relationship developing between the teenagers, and problems with longstanding friendships, and and and. And also hefty asides to teach bridge. I thought it was a lot of fun, though aspects of the plot were inevitable and therefore predictable.
A Princess In Theory I have a... complicated relationship with romance. In theory, I should love romance. I certainly love reading about romance books. In practice I am more likely to like reading books that are more what I would call "romance-adjacent"--there's a relationship story there, but there's another main focus to it. One rule that usually works for me is to avoid books with royalty in the title -- like anything "The Duke's Mistress" or whatever. Because I do enjoy reading about romances, I have heard rather a lot about Alyssa Cole, so I was quite willing to break that rule and test whether I would like this book. I kind of do. The protagonist is an epidemiologist! Very timely (even before the pandemic. We always knew the pandemic was coming). (this book does not have a pandemic in it)
I did like it, and I understand why Alyssa Cole has such stalwart fans. Among the pluses: it's sort of a Wakanda novel: the fictional African country has managed to mostly avoid colonization and so therefore is more prosperous and less unequal than other countries. Though there's some weird justification for the excesses of the palace. Cole is quite clearly trying to have her twirly princess dress and her social justice too, and that's fine. A strong plus for some people (including me at some time in the past) is its sex positivity. In romance categories I think it is what is called "sexy" rather than "erotic:" if I understand the difference, the former has sex in it, the latter is centered on sex or sexuality (and pornography is writing that is sex itself). At this stage of my life, written sex is very "meh" to me, so that after the first sex scene, I skipped forward over the others. I don't know why! I do the same with most fight and battle scenes.
The romance was fine, the descriptions of not-Wakanda were very nice, the slice of life in New York were nice. I wasn't satisfied with the mystery B plot. I felt that it could have been a lot more interesting and consequential. The revelation of what happened with the protagonist's parents seemed to me to fall flat completely--as if Cole had actually worked out something that made full sense, had consequence, and actually explained what happened--and then didn't write it into the final draft because of word limits or deadlines or ennui or something.
Jepp This is based on the existence, at Tycho Brahe's Uraniborg castle, of a Dutch dwarf named Jepp and a tippling moose. It tells a fictional tale of how he got there and what he did after he got there. I tried checking on the romance but wasn't able to verify it. I hope it was true. I'm certain that the family origins are fictional, and his life at the court of the Infanta in Brussels: though her fondness for dwarfs and what she put them through is historical fact. The high drama and angst of the book are not just provided by the harrowing events in it, but also by the fact that they are the reminiscences of an innocent teenager in the wide world for the first time. Characters have depth, and the landscape is well-drawn. I just finished it and that's why I'm finally writing these books up!
Tags: